Topic:  Middle and Secondary Students and Literacy

"I am beginning to wonder whether there is a political and public mindset that literacy learning is critical only in early childhood. The faulty and misguided assumption, ‘If young children learn to read early on, they will read to learn throughout their lives,’ results in more harm than good."

Richard Vacca, past President, International Reading Association

It is important for educators to recognize that as students get older the types of skill and strategy instruction we provide in our classrooms must change to meet the developmental levels of our students.  When these students do not respond to typical classroom instruction, we must know what types of intervention methods are available and appropriate for our students.  The following is a list of on-line resources to facilitate middle and secondary teachers in improving the literacy development of their students.  These resources expand on the foundational information found in chapter one ofBrozo, W.G., & Simpson, M.L. (1999). Readers, teachers, learners: Expanding literacy across the content areas (3rd Edition). New Jersey: Merrill Prentice Hall.

Tips from Instructional Specialists (Reading)

Bulleted lists provide frameworks for understand seven components of good instructional practice as it relates to reading and literacy instruction.  The topics covered include:  

bullet Profile of a Strategic Reader
bullet Reading/Listening for Literary Experiences
bullet What a Student and Teachers Must Know to Do Well in Reading on MSPAP
bullet A Reader's Checklist For Success in Reading for Literary Experience
bullet Checklist for Assuring Effective Instruction
bullet A Summary of Understanding Literature by Judith A. Langer
bullet A Reader’s Checklist in Reading to Perform a Task

These tips reflect "best practice" and are general enough to apply to all ages of students.  This site particularly addresses a question posed on page 4 in our textbook (Brozo, W.G., & Simpson, M.L. (1999). Readers, teachers, learners: Expanding literacy across the content areas (3rd Edition). New Jersey: Merrill Prentice Hall):  What is literacy and its role in middle and secondary school?  This site also underscores the principles addressed in chapter one of this book, indicating that language-based learning is a social process; it is best when delivered whole, functional, and meaningful; students need many opportunities to use reading and writing as vehicles for learning; students must be motivated to want to read and write; and the pursuit for literacy is a lifelong process.

By-Pass and Intervention Strategies for Students who Struggle

   This site provides a list of strategies for helping struggling readers.  Areas addressed include attention, ordering, memory, social considerations, higher order thinking, neuromotor difficulties, and language.  This site suggests that if teachers can identify difficulties their students are having they can employ strategies to help the students overcome or compensate for the difficulties and become more successful in the classroom.  These strategies are particularly applicable for middle and high school students who have the cognitive development to be able to monitor their own learning. 

Soar to Success

    This site provides three extensive articles related to reading and literacy intervention with older (above grade three) students.  The articles include, "Stopping Reading Failure", "Using Soar To Success with Special Education Students," and "Summary of Research Report."  This site would be useful to teachers who are looking for research-based information to try and understand the role of intervention, the needs of struggling readers, instructional strategies that facilitate students in developing comprehension, and the application of SUCCESS (an intervention program for older learners).  Emphasis is given to special needs learners in the regular classroom and an extensive bibliography provides opportunities for continued research on these topics. 

A District-Wide Commitment to Struggling Readers

This site explains the Madison Metropolitan School District's plan to address the reading needs of their students.  The school district planned its intervention strategies based on research that found the following situations in regard to high school students:

  1. Struggling readers may receive no additional instruction in reading that continues to build their reading abilities.
  2. Struggling readers may receive reading instruction in remedial programs that are isolated from the learning demands expected of them the rest of the day in their content classes.
  3. Struggling readers are frequently expected to perform independently in their content classrooms without the benefit of teaching strategies that foster their learning and without the availability of additional support, such as tutoring.
  4. Struggling readers may have to cope with learning in high school with no access to professionals trained in the teaching of reading.

Information is provided that outlines ten commitments the school system is making to improve the literacy levels of high school students.  Particularly interesting is the emphasis on reading instruction in the content areas.  Every teacher is a teacher of reading.  Other sources of information on this page include tables of pre-reading, during reading, and post-reading that demonstrate the different types of behaviors exhibited between "struggling" and "strong" readers.  The section at the bottom of the site provides a list of ways that the classroom teacher can contribute to a school-wide emphasis on literacy development.  

Research Conclusions Crucial to the Teaching of Reading

Because I am focusing on chapter one ((Brozo, W.G., & Simpson, M.L. (1999). Readers, teachers, learners: Expanding literacy across the content areas (3rd Edition). New Jersey: Merrill Prentice Hall) which provides an overview of the challenges of teaching reading with older students, the status of literacy in our schools, and how language-based classrooms facilitate literacy development, this site helps to reinforce the research noted in chapter one.  Seventeen research-based conclusions are listed to provide teachers with the information needed to implement "best practices" in their classrooms.  Perhaps the most significant aspect of this site is the extensive bibliography listed at the end of the page.  

Muskingum College:  Center for Advancement of Learning - Learning Strategies Database:  Reading Comprehension

This site is one of the most extensive I have seen in an on-line database on reading comprehension strategies.  These strategies are applicable for a wide range of ages. The website begins with providing background information on reading comprehension, describing the behaviors of good and poor readers, reasons for poor comprehension, and how teachers can troubleshoot to ensure proper comprehension.  The remainder of the site provides many strategies for improving comprehension.  These strategies are divided into categories:  

bullet General Fix-Up Strategies; 
bullet Increasing Reading Rate; 
bullet Challenging Reading Material; 
bullet Books on Tape; 
bullet Reading Strategies for ESL/EFL Students; 
bullet Reading Preparation for Standardized Tests; 
bullet Textbook Notetaking; 
bullet Group Activity for Content Reading; 
bullet Study Groups for Reading; 
bullet Graphic Organizers for Merging Reading and Cooperative Strategies; 
bullet Discussion Continuum; 
bullet Building Active Readers through Debate; 
bullet Non-text Reading Comprehension; 
bullet Reading Foreign Language Texts; 
bullet Reading Science Material; 
bullet Staying Alert While Reading; 
bullet Summary Writing; 
bullet Creating Interest; 
bullet Improving Comprehension; 
bullet Improving Motivation;
bullet General Approach to Unfamiliar Vocabulary Words;
bullet Predictions Based on Context;
bullet Word Elements:  Affixes and Roots;
bullet Antonyms, Synonyms and Related Approaches;
bullet LINCS Strategy;
bullet Dissect Strategy;
bullet CSSD Strategy;
bullet Vocab Game;
bullet Graphic Organizers and Groups;
bullet Patterned Language Approach;
bullet Teaching Vocabulary:  Do's and Don'ts;
bullet Strategies Related to Organization;
bullet Textbook Organization;
bullet Text Skimming;
bullet Creative Mapping for Content Reading;
bullet Mediated Instruction of Text (MIT) for Content Reading;
bullet SQ3R Strategy;
bullet PQ4R Strategy;
bullet RAP Strategy;
bullet SNIPS Strategy;
bullet PARTS:  A Text Perusal Strategy;
bullet REAP Strategy;
bullet Multipass Strategy;
bullet PRSR Strategy;
bullet PROR Strategy;
bullet Textbook Reading Guides;
bullet Exercises in Meaningful Organization;
bullet KWL Strategy;
bullet Directed Reading Activity (DRA);
bullet Directed Reading-Thinking Activity (DRTA);
bullet Story Star/Story Maps Strategy;
bullet Gleaning

Educators should be able to identify comprehension problems in their classrooms and use this site to locate strategies to use to improve students' abilities to comprehend written materials.  

Bibliography of Resources for Middle and Secondary Teachers that Facilitate Student Literacy

Yellow Brick Roads : Shared and Guided Paths to Independent Reading 4-12
by Janet Allen

 
(October 2000)
Stenhouse Pub; ISBN: 1571103198

 

 

There's Room for Me Here : Literacy Workshop in the Middle School
by Janet Allen, Kyle Gonzalez

 (November 1997)
Stenhouse Pub; ISBN: 1571100423

 

 

 

It's Never Too Late : Leading Adolescents to Lifelong Literacy
by Janet Allen, Tom Romano

(December 1995)
Heinemann (Txt); ISBN: 0435088394

 

 

In the Middle : New Understandings About Writing, Reading, and Learning
by Nancie Atwell, Nancy Atwell

2nd edition (March 1998)
Boynton/Cook Pub; ISBN: 0867093749

 

 

Nonfiction Matters : Reading, Writing, and Research in Grades 3-8
by Stephanie Harvey

 
(June 1998)
Stenhouse Pub; ISBN: 1571100725

 

 

Teaching Reading in Middle School (Grades 5 & Up)
by Laura Robb

 Paperback - 352 pages (August 1, 2000)
Scholastic Prof Book Div; ISBN: 0590685600

 

 

Reading for Understanding
by Ruth Schoenbach, Cynthia Greenleaf, Christine Cziko, Lori Hurwitz

 
(December 1999)
Jossey-Bass; ISBN: 0787950459

 

 

 

I Read It, but I Don't Get It : Comprehension Strategies for Adolescent Readers
by Cris Tovani, Ellin Oliver Keene

(October 2000)
Stenhouse Pub; ISBN: 157110089X

 

04/28/2003 11:26:33 PM     Hit Counter